Managing Water Volatility: From Extreme Drought to Sudden Flooding
Analysis of water volatility, from North Carolina droughts to New Jersey flooding, and the role of evaporation management in climate resilience.
By Editorial Team ·
The rapid oscillation between severe water shortages and sudden flooding events is forcing municipalities to rethink how they stabilize local water supplies.
This week in water
- Durham faces a critical shortage with only 80 days of water remaining as drought conditions persist (WRAL).
- New Jersey has transitioned from a two-year drought into a period characterized by heavy storms and flooding (Asbury Park Press).
- Releases at Gavins Point Dam are being lowered to maintain necessary water supply rates (DRGNews).
- Federal officials are being urged to develop comprehensive plans for managing the dual threats of floods and droughts (University of California, Riverside).
- A drought in Kittery has depleted the water supply, resulting in a freeze on new housing connections (Seacoastonline.com).
- Intensifying drought in eastern North Carolina is impacting agricultural productivity, prompting conservation pleas (WITN).
- Water conservation efforts are being heavily encouraged across central and eastern North Carolina due to worsening drought (The Wake Weekly).
- While recent flooding has provided some relief to Lake Powell, significant drought concerns persist for the region (ABC4 Utah).
The cycle of hydrological volatility
The news cycles from North Carolina to New Jersey reveal a pattern of extreme hydrological volatility. We are seeing a simultaneous emergence of localized droughts that halt economic development—such as the housing delays in Kittery—and intense rainfall events that test infrastructure. This oscillation makes traditional water management difficult because the tools used to combat one extreme can sometimes exacerbate the other.
When reservoirs are low, as seen in the reports regarding Durham and eastern North Carolina, the primary driver of loss is often evaporation. As water levels drop, the exposed surface area of a reservoir can become a massive source of loss, particularly when high temperatures and wind increase the rate of moisture transfer to the atmosphere. For agricultural regions, this loss is a direct threat to food security, as seen in the impacts reported by WITN.
However, the “relief” provided by flooding, such as the recent boost to Lake Powell, is often temporary and creates its own set of engineering challenges. Managing these “boom and bust” cycles requires a shift from reactive measures to proactive storage management. This involves not just finding more water, but ensuring that once water is captured, it is not immediately lost to the atmosphere.
Physics of loss: why drought accelerates
To understand why drought-stricken areas like Durham or Kittery are so vulnerable, one must look at the energy balance of open water. Evaporation is not merely a result of heat; it is a complex interaction between solar radiation, wind speed, and the vapor pressure gradient between the water surface and the air.
In many drought scenarios, the air becomes increasingly dry, which increases the vapor pressure deficit. This deficit acts as a “suction” force, pulling more moisture out of the water body. Furthermore, as seen in the research by Harbeck (1962), wind plays a critical role through aerodynamic mass transfer; even moderate winds can strip the layer of saturated air sitting just above the water surface, significantly accelerating loss.
This creates a feedback loop. As a reservoir shrinks, the remaining water often becomes shallower and warmer, which can further increase evaporation rates. For municipal managers, the goal is to break this loop by manipulating the variables of the Penman-Monteith equation. By reducing the surface area or blocking the energy inputs (sunlight and wind), the evaporation rate can be suppressed.
Strategies for stabilizing supply
When facing the “80 days of water” reality described by WRAL, managers often look toward methods to reduce evaporation to stretch existing supplies. There are several tiers of intervention, ranging from low-cost biological approaches to high-engineering modular systems.
- Biological and Natural Barriers: Using duckweed or palm fronds can provide some degree of shading. While these are often region-specific and have limited scalability, they offer a low-tech way to reduce light penetration and wind fetch.
- Chemical Interventions: Chemical monolayers use surfactants to create a thin film on the water. While cost-effective and capable of 20–40% reduction (Craig et al. 2005), they are highly sensitive to wind and temperature and require frequent reapplication.
- Physical Covers: This is the most aggressive form of control. Shade balls can reduce evaporation by approximately 66–75% in field studies, though they may impact water chemistry. For higher performance, floating modular covers are used. According to manufacturer data, products like the Rhombo Hexoshield can achieve up to 98% reduction (AWTT) by providing nearly complete surface coverage and high wind resistance (AWTT).
The choice of method often depends on the intended use of the water. For example, if the water is intended for municipal drinking supply, managers must ensure any covering solution—whether it is a geomembrane cover or a modular tile—is compliant with safety standards like NSF/FDA.
Balancing the extremes
The ultimate challenge highlighted by the University of California, Riverside, is the need for a plan that accounts for both floods and droughts. A resilient system must be able to capture the “boost” from a flood (as seen in Lake Powell) and hold it securely through the next drought.
This requires a multi-layered approach. During high-rainfall periods, infrastructure must be capable of managing high inflows without failing. During dry periods, the focus must shift to minimizing the latent heat flux and preventing the storage from “bleeding” into the atmosphere.
Integrating floating solar into this equation offers a dual benefit: it provides shade to reduce evaporation while generating the power needed to run water treatment and pumping infrastructure. While the capital costs are higher, the combination of energy production and water preservation aligns well with the long-term need for climate-resilient infrastructure.
As water volatility becomes the new baseline, the ability to control the interface between water and atmosphere will likely become one of the most important tools in municipal and agricultural management.
Frequently asked questions
- How much water can be saved using floating covers?
- Modular floating covers typically achieve 65–80% reductions in field studies (Mady et al. 2021), while some high-performance options like Rhombo Hexoshield can reach up to 98% (AWTT).
- Can evaporation control help during a drought?
- Yes, by reducing the amount of water lost to the atmosphere, [storage management](/methods/storage-management) helps preserve existing reservoir levels for longer periods.